The "grace only" advocates in the church boldly declare that
man is saved 100% by the grace of God. They proclaim that man does
not contribute one whit to his salvation. They would have their
listeners to believe that when one teaches man to save himself from
this untoward generation, he is teaching legalism.
One of the "proof-texts" for their position is Luke 17:10, "So
likewise, ye, when ye shall have done all those things which are
commanded you, say, We are unprofitable servants: we have done that
which was our duty to do. " The argument is that even though we do
all the things commanded we are still "unprofitable." Therefore, we
had to have been saved 100% by the grace of God, and that nothing we
did contributed to our being saved in the least.
In this verse, Jesus was not teaching about the necessity of
our obedience. Jesus was teaching about one's attitude toward his
salvation. Salvation is never earned regardless of the amount of
obedient acts performed. Even the most obedient is unworthy of the
blessing he will reap. Salvation will ever be a free, undeserved,
unmerited gift of a loving and kind God. This should be the
attitude of all the faithful. We should bow our heads before God's
throne, and say, "We are unprofitable servants."
This is a far cry from saying that nothing we do contributes to
our salvation. Jesus himself said in Matt. 7:21, "Not every one
that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of
heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in
heaven." Didn't Jesus know that we do not do anything to get into
heaven? Did He contradict His words found in Luke 17:10? Certainly
not! Man must "save himself" (Acts 2:40). Does this obedience earn
him his salvation? No!
Man must contribute to his salvation everything God has told
him to contribute. To say that man contributes nothing to his
redemption is to say that God requires nothing of him. The ultimate
end of such a doctrine would be universalism for the Bible teaches
that God's grace has appeared unto all men (Tit. 2:11).
There is a great difference between saying that we do not earn
our salvation and saying that one does not contribute one whit to
his salvation. The first statement harmonizes with Jesus' words of
Luke 17:10. We are unprofitable servants. The latter statement,
however, is false doctrine. The teaching should be rejected, and
those who teach it should be marked and avoided (Rom. 16:17-18).